
So the twood (mood on Twitter) this morning was pretty funny. Peeps were seemingly blindsided by the late-breaking Girls onslaught in the form of Pitchfork's
trotting out of the gate on a Friday morning with a Tom Breihan-curated Best New Music for the San Francisco band's debut album, Album.
Self-Titled magazine told Breihan it agreed with him and wanted to put them on its next cover waaaay before FADER (ahead of the curve on a lot of things) decided to do so.
Rob Mitchum wished he had come out disliking Girls "before Girls Backlash Day."
Chris Weingarten (@1000TimesYes) said the album is "just pretty good," reminding his twaudience of the 7/10 he gave it in one of his 140-character reviews.
Breihan replied, "Bring it on, kids!," adding that he tried to give Separation Sunday a 9.2 back in the day.
Mitchum clarified: the bad on Album outweighs the good.
I said the three great songs carry the weight of the bad ones.
Weingarten replied: Or the one great song.
Burn.
Meanwhile, PopMatters doesn't care about Album.
Tiny Mix Tapes doesn't care either UPDATE: a 4/5, but not really enough actual words to do it justice.
Coke Machine Glow digs it 81 percent.
Rolling Stone (who cares?) gave it its favorite designation ever, a 3.5. Yawn.
And finally, I gave it a 4/5 over at Baeble.
Thanks to Idolator for inspiring this format of blog entry (a revue of reviews).
Photo: Nicole Leighton via Girls' MySpace.