
![]()
Neko Case's album, well-received by everyone from Sasha Frere-Jones in The New Yorker to Paste Magazine, Pitchfork, SPIN, The Guardian, and The Onion, debuted on the Billboard album chart at 3, slipped to 17 in its second week, and is now at 28. Well, with bands like Twiztid now in the mix, what do you expect? Also, Kelly Clarkson flew in to the number-one spot last week, with that lollipop-like cover begging a purchase, or at the very least a stream. But I imagine it's one of those albums that was recorded too loud and gives the listener a jump upon first listen. From the 30-second samples on iTunes, it sounds like it has about three quality pop numbers on it.
"Middle Cyclone," meanwhile, has many more great tracks, but squarely none of them is a pop song, so it is a triumph that the album is swimming so strongly in the mainstream. I would go as far as Frere-Jones did in saying that it is her best album yet. But its trajectory to the listener is the opposite of its trajectory on the Billboard chart, as these things often go. The more experimental instrumentation--namely a bunch of old pianos, the saxophone on the stunning "Red Tide," a dulcimer and traditional strings--hit you first, followed by the complex arrangements. Yes, the traditional song structure lies skeletally there on every track, but she leaps out of the constraints frequently.
Listen closely for the way "Fever" transforms itself into a march of powerful vocals halfway through. "People Got A Lot of Nerve" manages to be both intrinsically Neko, but melodically bold. "I'm An Animal" is randomly this modern classic rock ballad, a pleasant, energetic rhythm full of strong but simple chord strums. "Prison Girls," which follows it, returns Case to her drawling guitar howling, but surprises with pepperings of pizzicatto strings, an oddly confident exploration of a confused identity, and a nice little assonant refrain that alternates with the chorus, "I love your long shadows / and your gunpowder eyes." Case is intrinsically herself a lot, primarily because her time signatures all verge on, or simply are, a waltz. But there is enough else going on that this becomes unimportant on subsequent listens.
In the past few week's flurry of new albums to listen to including the (overrated) "It's Blitz," "Living Things," "Fever Ray," and "Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix," "Middle Cyclone" got tossed aside after a couple of weeks of concentrated intimacy. But there are so many more layers to peel off this onion.
What I liked about "Fox Confessor Brings the Flood" (2006) was how diverse and sort of uncompetitive it was. "Hold On, Hold On" is still one of my favorite songs of hers and is one of many that seem quickly forgotten. But then, Neko Case isn't about hits, whether she's on the Billboard chart or not. Each fan has their own hits on their own chart.
Photo credit: Neko Case's Myspace page.