Record stores are about more than just records. They also happen to be the seat of some of the most unique and exciting musical events, especially on April 18, when this year's second annual Record Store Day is held. Surprising groupings of musicians band together, as Beck and Sonic Youth are doing by "covering each other," Stereogum reported in February. Limited editions of merch and music are sold and general revelry takes place. The old hat independent music store is put up on a pedestal. For one day, revenue models are forgotten.
What some people might find surprising is that, according to Nielsen SoundScan, more long-players were sold in 2008 than in any other year. Admittedly, the club scene around the world is strong. (Would you believe there are other DJs in the world than Samantha Ronson? Well, yes, you would, because you are a Dear Reader of Lizzyville and you are smart and snobby and never read People magazine.) But people are also realizing or remembering that LPs are the purest form of recording there is. CDs are utter crap, but of course they slightly edge out mp3s because their digital quality can be tailored by the user. But don't forget about "Imperfect Sound Forever." LPs are collectors' items and they are wonderful to listen to. Joanna Newsom discussed the simple, organic process of listen to an LP straight through in a Wire interview awhile back. (And it's online! Go read it now!)
The independent record store of legend, I argue in today's Record Store Day feature on findingDulcinea, is a place staffed by attentive
and knowledgeable music enthusiasts, curious patrons, listening booths
and limited-edition offerings alongside anticipated releases, all
encouraging leisurely exploration and education.
But browsing a music store is no longer the preferred purchasing method.
Amazon routinely offers deep discounts and free shipping, the blog
Technologizer points out. Affordable subscription plans from retailers
like eMusic also entice users away from the tactile but more
time-consuming process of visiting a physical store. If one digital
music store doesn’t offer what a consumer wants, another likely will.
And if a store doesn't, a torrent does.
An interesting discussion on the matter is circling the Web. Idolator and NME's Luke Lewis both argue that, hey, maybe it's not such a bad thing for these stores to die out. Don't we need better representation of artists in organizations like the ERA, record labels, PR firms and (evil) tour companies? Is this a futile cause?
In The Telegraph, the ERA's Kim Bayley called record stores "a heady mixture of unofficial youth club, cultural centre, recruitment
agency for musicians and music education centre. They recommend new
music and they nurture new artists.”
Guess what? The Internet can do all those things. If influential Web sites such as Pitchfork are any indication, music
fans still turn to others—critics and music bloggers—for curated views
of new music. We arguably don't need record store employees anymore. Also, some of them are virtually unapproachable, which Luke Lewis kind of hints at. Wired reported extensively on the “Pitchfork effect” in
2006, citing the Toronto band Broken Social Scene as just one band
whose success has been significantly bolstered by Pitchfork’s praise. It certainly doesn't hurt that Pitchfork and others organize mega festivals to help boost artists' incomes--and their own, so they can keep paying writers to curate the large promo pile.
“[M]ost listeners still find their music with the assistance of a
filter: a reliable source that sifts through millions of tracks to help
them choose what they do (and don't) want to hear,” Wired’s Dave
Itzkoff said.
I believe the live music scene will be huge, and clearly I'm not the only one. But the trouble is keeping the companies that organize these events above board. They are clearly verging on conglomerate/titan status and it scares the crap out of me. I am tired of paying $20 surcharges to see Neko Case, to dance to a Hercules & Love Affair DJ set, to wave a glowing cell phone at David Byrne, to see David Longstreth and Ed Droste in one place.
But the Internet makes things easy and it makes us stingy.
Read the rest of my article here.